Obesity rates in the United States have skyrocketed over the last twenty years, with no end in sight provoking former Surgeon General, Richard Carmona to state that "obesity is a terror within. It is destroying our society... more » from within and unless we do something about it, the magnitude of the dilemma will dwarf 9/11 or any other terrorist event that you can point out..."
As this epidemic of obesity reaches out into even the most remote corners of the globe, only one thing seems clear, the issue is more complex than you could ever imagine.
Seeking to trace the problem to it's root, we find ourselves in the African Savannah 4 million years ago where we discover how our hunter gatherer ancestry, when mixed in with our modern environment of convenience, stress and abundance has led us to become the most obese generation in the history of the world. Perhaps an even more sobering fact is that we're the first modern society to raise a generation of children with a projected life expectancy that is shorter than that of their parents.
One of the film's most compelling characters is found in Brooke Bates, who after struggling with her weight for all her young life, resorted to liposuction and a tummy tuck at age 12 (all caught on camera). Where the media blitz around the surgery focused on her age and questioning her parents judgment, our documentary camera's dug deeper between the lines to address the confluence of emotional and environmental factors which lead Brooke and so many other young people down a contentious path of food addiction and self loathing.
Beyond the shocking medical statistics and newspaper headlines that one would expect, Killer at Large also examines the ethical and moral implications of the obesity epidemic with leaders of several world religions who sight scripture calling all believers to live healthful lives free of overindulgence and laziness, characteristics that are sadly becoming the norm.
The film goes on to expose the public policies that have been institutionalized by the government and their industrial paymasters who have worked to create an infrastructure that forces farmers to over-produce all the wrong kinds of foods for mass consumption. Add to that further policies that force the price of vegetables artificially high and the price of intensely processed food artificially low, making the poor uniquely positioned to suffer from the results of public policy on obesity.
Other policies and government programs that contribute to obesity are also explored, including those in our schools that are making our children obese. From George Bush's No Child Left Behind proposals and the Federal School Lunch Program to budget cuts and vending machines, America's public schools are becoming the perfect storm of conditions causing unprecedented weight gain in our nation's youth.
But most frightening of all are the National Security implications, causing Carmona to wonder, "Where will our soldiers, sailors and airmen come from? Where will our police and firemen come from if the youngsters today are on a trajectory that says that they will be obese?"
In fact, the problems with the military are presenting themselves now. According to Dr. Linda Kinsinger (U.S. Dept. of Veteran's Affairs) 71% of our veterans are overweight or obese and they suffer more amputations due to type 2 diabetes than from war-related injuries.
Clearly, America is on the wrong path and drastic action is needed to reverse this pandemic weight gain that is negatively affecting every segment of our population. Like Dr. Lionel Tiger says in the film, "It's a battle we fight three times a day and we've all been drafted. It's truly the most democratic of wars."« less
Matthew G. Sherwin | last seen screaming at Amazon customer service | 10/16/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Killer At Large is a very good documentary that explores the obesity epidemic and the major causes of obesity along with the politics, social issues and even the health problems caused by obesity. The film progresses at a very good pace and I was never bored; the people interviewed gave insightful comments that were very relevant and we get both sides of the story although admittedly the film focuses on the people who support the viewpoints of the filmmakers. The quality of the print is very good, too.
We see practically everything on this topic; this film is well done indeed. For example, the footage of former US Surgeon General Richard Carmona shows him telling audiences that "obesity is the terror within; and unless we do something about it, the magnitude of the dilemma will dwarf 9/11 or any other terrorist event you can point out to me." Wow, what a statement! But the facts are there to support his claims: we are inundated with medical statistics and testimony from people from all walks of life that obesity is a fantastically serious problem that merits our immediate attention. Indeed, the film begins with us meeting a twelve year old girl, Brooke Bates, who has not been able to control her weight. Her parents willingly sign her up for liposuction despite her tender age! Yes, the liposuction procedure and an additional tummy tuck work wonders for her while she exercises--until, that is, she regains the weight that she lost; and by the end of the film we learn that she's going with her parents for an even more invasive procedure even though she's still only thirteen!
And it isn't just Brooke Bates. Bill Clinton goes on record as saying that obesity is a killer; and he's right. We get great comments from Dr. Linda Kinsinger who is the Director of The VA National Center for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention that "71% of our veterans are overweight or obese;" and people like Ralph Nader and Neil LaBute (film director and author of the book entitled "Fat Pig") all share their stories about the horrors of people practically eating their way into the grave. Meme Roth of National Action Against Obesity also has plenty to say on this topic and the issues surrounding it.
But there's so much more in this film. The film show how junk food companies kiss up to members of Congress and others to get their vending machines distributed practically everywhere we look; this means that we can't go too far without seeing a cue that we should be eating or drinking some very calorie-rich food. Companies like Frito Lay and McDonalds can buy their ways into everyone's home; their commercials are designed to look like regular Saturday morning cartoons and this takes advantage of the fact that very young kids under the age of eight typically cannot distinguish between commercials and regular television programming. The commercials lead young kids to believe that if they eat at McDonalds everything they will live happily ever after! In addition, I love the part in the film when one mother complains to a panel of representatives from fast food companies that their commercials are undermining her ability to teach her children to eat healthy food and to stay away from junk food. We also get comments by a school lunch worker who says that the quality of lunches is so poor because of the way the federal government reimburses schools for their lunch programs--the school must give a certain minimum of calories to each student; and if they gave a healthy lunch they wouldn't meet the calorie minimum requirement and thus they would lose their lunch program funding!
There's actually much more in this film so if you think I've given it all away and spoiled it for you I can happily assure you that this is not the case. The DVD also comes with extras; I liked the deleted scenes in particular. There is even an abridged version for educational purposes in the classroom; but hopefully teachers can show the complete version to school kids as soon as they're able to follow along.
The only thing I didn't care for is that the film doesn't focus enough on the incredible self-discipline that it really, really takes to lose weight. In many cases (but certainly not all) there simply isn't any excuse or alternative for losing weight--you need to exercise more and eat smaller amounts of food that is very healthy for you. In the past whenever I have been overweight, as I am now, this has been the only method I ever tried that worked for me when I wanted to become thinner. In addition, they show George W. Bush encouraging exercise but they do it in a way that seems to mock him and belittle his sincerity. While I was not sorry to see Mr. Bush leave office several months ago, I don't see why they should mock him for encouraging people to exercise. Otherwise this is a very good film.
Killer at Large does a fine job of exploring the serious epidemic of obesity and the terrible health problems that result from many, many people being way too overweight. I recommend this film for people studying the obesity epidemic; this film should be mandatory viewing for school kids once they are old enough to learn from it. Moreover, people who are overweight like me should watch this film and perhaps gain enough strength from it to be brave and do something constructive about losing weight."
Obesity: Enemy of Good Health
The Movie Man | Maywood, New Jersey USA | 04/26/2009
(3 out of 5 stars)
""Killer at Large" is a documentary that looks at many of the causes of overweight in America, including problems with school lunches and vending machines and the impact food lobbyists have on determining government policy. There are also stories about young people who have had gastric bypass or liposuction surgery. Interviews recount how many people, including Bill Clinton, have tried to bring attention to the obesity problem. Beyond the shocking medical statistics and newspaper headlines, "Killer at Large" examines the ethical and moral implications of the obesity epidemic with leaders of several world religions, who cite scripture that calls for living a healthful life free of overindulgence and laziness. Bonus features include deleted scenes about menu labeling, the closing of a McDonald's in Tavistock, the sugar lobby vs. the World Health Organization, and a hidden-camera interview with a McDonald's vice president."
This film is EPIC.......
Evelyn Black | L.A.,Ca | 07/14/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Remember how Doctors promoted cigarettes at one time?!!! BE informed! MOST of our government is NOT watching out for our health and our children's future, so I can see why Bill Clinton and Arnold Schwarzenegger have tried to help out. They've experienced it first-hand. Wonder why you'd spend a little extra on that fashionable bag, but not on fresh food? Watch this film. Wonder why a gas station, school, fabric store now carries junk food? Watch this film. This film goes over EVERY aspect of why we should all start eating organic foods, and so far my whole family has benefited immensely from this knowledge. *Big Thanks to Bryan Young & crew*"
Great info but very disturbing
A. Gallardo | Valencia, CA | 02/14/2010
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Great movie on the obvious problem in America, we eat too much and move too little. Hilarious segments on the government's attempts to address the problem. Also, a great reminder on the power the food industry has over politicians. The story of the young girl going through countless bariatric surgeries is heartbreaking. Overall very entertaining."
On American Obesity
stoic | Mobile AL | 12/21/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Killer at Large is an insightful, thorough look at America's obesity crisis. Viewers who watch this film will come away with a good understanding of the depth of this problem. The film also does a good job of explaining the corporate and political interests that oppose efforts to change the way we eat.
Killer at Large is at its best when it discusses the impact of obesity on America's children. The film details the appalling steps taken by corporate America to sell kids junk food; the film also explains the rapidly kids' declining health. Killer at Large shows Brooke Bates, a 218-pound 12-year-old undergoing liposuction in an effort to slim down - and gain acceptance from her peers at school. Bates' story tugs at the viewer's heartstrings.
The film also explains some of the efforts to fight obesity. The viewer hears about the effort to ban snack foods in schools. (Amazingly, when California institutes such a ban, there is massive resistance both from students and their parents). We also hear of a Massachusetts town that has implemented plans to improve public health by encouraging exercise and by imploring its restaurants to serve healthier food. The overall tone of Killer at Large, however, is despairing.
If I had to be critical of Killer at Large I would say that the filmmakers' thinking is questionable at times. Killer at Large contains snickers at the Bush administration's promotion of exercise and personal responsibility and its use of public service announcements as means of fighting obesity (as opposed to asking Americans to change their diets). That the filmmakers rely on criticisms from Stephen Colbert, Bill Maher, and Ralph Nader provides some clue as to the politics of Killer at Large.
For what it's worth, I think that Bush did a poor job of responding to the obesity crisis and that the filmmakers are correct in stating that we must change our diets. I also think, however, that the filmmakers' politics cause them to dismiss without apparent reflection the potential good that can come from some of the current anti-obesity programs. After the Surgeon General's 1964 statement on the ills of smoking, it took multiple programs administered over decades for many Americans to stop using tobacco; sadly, I suspect that it may take at least that long for many of us to adopt healthier diets.
Despite my quibbles, I highly recommend Killer at Large. This film will make you think.